Aaron BensonREALTOR® · Realty ONE GroupTalk to Aaron

Area comparison

McCormick Ranch vs. Central Scottsdale: master plan, lots, homes and HOAs

The short answer

Both are in the City of Scottsdale, so the main differences are the plan and the HOAs.

McCormick Ranch is a single established master plan with greenbelt paths, lakes and common HOAs, mostly from the 1970s to the 1990s, while Central Scottsdale is a mix of established neighborhoods near Shea Boulevard and the 101, from the 1970s to the 2000s, where HOAs vary. Their market figures come from different ZIP codes, and McCormick Ranch’s 85258 also covers neighboring areas.

McCormick Ranch and Central Scottsdale at a glance

McCormick Ranch and Central Scottsdale, side by side
FactorMcCormick RanchCentral Scottsdale
ZIP median list price$1,425,000RentCast, ZIP 85258 (which extends well beyond McCormick Ranch), October 2026$1,285,000RentCast, ZIP 85260 (one of Central Scottsdale’s two ZIP codes), October 2026
ZIP days on market (listings)33 daysRentCast, ZIP 85258 (which extends well beyond McCormick Ranch), October 202638 daysRentCast, ZIP 85260 (one of Central Scottsdale’s two ZIP codes), October 2026
LotsTypical suburban lotsTypical suburban, with some larger lots
Typical homes1970s–90s single-family, many updated1970s–2000s, many remodeled
HOAsCommonVaries by neighborhood
SettingGreenbelt, lakes, pathsCentral, close to the 101 and Shea
WalkabilityModerate; paths connect neighborhoodsLow to moderate
Drive times (without traffic)Sky Harbor 27 min · Old Town 10 min · Scottsdale Airport 11 min · Loop 101 5 minSky Harbor 33 min · Old Town 19 min · Scottsdale Airport 12 min · Loop 101 7 min

RentCast last updated these figures on .

Market figures: RentCast, from single-family listings (list prices, not closed sales) in each area’s main ZIP code. “To date” means the month so far. Silverleaf shares ZIP 85255 with North Scottsdale, so it shows no ZIP market figures of its own. Any figures shown are past results, not a forecast. Descriptions cover places and housing, not who lives there.

Municipality

Both areas are within the City of Scottsdale, so the same city zoning, permits and short-term rental rules apply to both. Check any parcel near the city’s edge. Choosing between them doesn’t change the city. It can change which association’s rules apply.

How each came about

  • McCormick Ranch is one master plan. According to the McCormick Ranch Property Owners’ Association, Kaiser-Aetna bought the 4,236-acre ranch in 1970, and the association’s articles were recorded on September 21, 1972.
  • Central Scottsdale isn’t one plan. It’s a group of established neighborhoods near Shea Boulevard and the 101, so what’s true of one subdivision may not hold for the next.

Lots

  • McCormick Ranch: typical suburban lots.
  • Central Scottsdale: typical suburban lots, with some larger ones.

Homes and when they were built

  • McCormick Ranch: single-family homes from the 1970s to the 1990s, many of them updated.
  • Central Scottsdale: homes from the 1970s to the 2000s, many of them remodeled.

A home built before 1978 needs the federal lead-based paint disclosure when sold, so check the year built in the older parts of either area.

HOAs

  • McCormick Ranch: common.
  • Central Scottsdale: varies by neighborhood.

In McCormick Ranch, ask which associations a home belongs to, and what each one charges. Arizona’s resale disclosure now calls for a statement when a property is subject to more than one association’s report and fee (A.R.S. § 33-1806). The McCormick Ranch HOA guide covers the McCormick Ranch Property Owners’ Association’s fees, lake rules, rental rule and approvals, from its own documents. In Central Scottsdale, the first question is whether the home has an HOA at all.

Setting

  • McCormick Ranch: a greenbelt, lakes and paths, with easy access to Old Town.
  • Central Scottsdale: central, close to the 101 and Shea.

Getting around

  • McCormick Ranch: moderate walkability, with paths connecting its neighborhoods.
  • Central Scottsdale: low to moderate walkability.

The City’s Scottsdale Trolley runs three fare-free circulator routes that connect with nine regional bus routes and one express route. Routes change, so check the current map against a specific address.

ZIP codes

Each area’s market figures come from its main ZIP code: 85258 for McCormick Ranch and 85260 for Central Scottsdale, which also includes 85259. The two areas don’t share one on this site, but 85258 also covers neighboring areas, so its figures aren’t a McCormick Ranch-only measure. Those figures are RentCast’s median list prices and days on market for single-family listings, not closed sales, and the table above dates them.

Neighborhood names and ZIP codes don’t settle where a home sits. Look up the parcel with the Maricopa County Assessor, and check its subdivision and recorded documents.

See them side by side

The table above comes from the same records as each area page. The compare tool shows this pair, or any other two areas. More detail is on the McCormick Ranch and Central Scottsdale pages. To talk through specific streets and homes, book a consultation.

About this comparison

General information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Your own contract controls, and your attorney, tax professional or other advisers can confirm what applies to you.

Boundaries are approximate, so check the parcel, its CC&Rs and the current code for any specific home.

Sources checked October 20 to 30, 2026. Rules and figures can change.

Sources

  1. McCormick Ranch Property Owners’ Association, community history, accessed October 30, 2026mrpoa.com
  2. A.R.S. § 33-1806, planned community resale disclosures, accessed October 30, 2026azleg.gov
  3. City of Scottsdale, transit system (updated October 28, 2026), accessed October 30, 2026scottsdaleaz.gov
  4. Maricopa County Assessor, parcel search, accessed October 20, 2026mcassessor.maricopa.gov

Next steps

Or ask Aaron directly.Talk to Aaron

The area pages

Deciding between McCormick Ranch and Central Scottsdale?

Talk it through with Aaron: the streets, the homes and the tradeoffs, in person, by phone or on video.

Talk to Aaron

Still deciding whether to move? That’s a good time to talk.

Call 602-785-5095Text 602-785-5095
1 saved home,Ask Aaron about these