Aaron BensonREALTOR® · Realty ONE GroupTalk to Aaron

Selling your home off-market

A private sale keeps your home off the MLS and out of public view: no yard sign, no listing photos online, no open houses. It’s an option, not the right choice for every home. You give up some of the market’s reach for privacy and control, and you can still go to the full market later.

This page explains the rules as of November 18, 2026. It isn’t legal, tax or financial advice, and the rules change; the sources are listed below.

Illustration of a brass key and ceramic vessel on a stone ledge beside an abstract doorway.

What a private sale is

Under ARMLS’s rules, a private (off-market) sale is usually an Office Exclusive listing: the seller directs the listing brokerage that the home not be put in the MLS and not be publicly marketed. It’s still a listing, with a written listing agreement and a licensed agent representing the seller.

A second option, Coming Soon, delays public marketing instead of skipping it. The home is entered in the MLS, but it isn’t shown on public websites through IDX or sent to the listing portals for up to 30 days.

Some people also say “off-market” for a sale a seller arranges directly with a buyer they already know, a neighbor, say, or a tenant. That’s possible too, and a seller can have an agent handle it.

What it gives you

Privacy: while the home is private, it isn’t on a yard sign, a listing site or social media, and no photos of the inside are published. There’s no public record of a listing price or of how long it was for sale.

Fewer showings, each one planned: there are no open houses. Visits are set up ahead of time, when it suits you, and fewer people know the home is for sale or when it’s empty.

A say in what’s shared: details go out one conversation at a time, and you decide how much to share: the photos, the floor plan, the price, your reasons for moving.

Buyers ready to act: if you want, every buyer is asked for the same thing before a showing, a prequalification letter or proof of funds.

Time to decide: you see the interest first, then choose whether to stay private or go to the full market. If you already have a buyer in view, a private sale can also be simpler than listing first.

What it costs you

Fewer buyers: the MLS puts a home in front of every agent and buyer in the market at once, and a private sale gives that up. With fewer buyers competing, you may get a lower price, or wait longer for the right one. Nobody can say in advance whether that will happen; it depends on the home, the market and the timing.

Fewer agents can bring a buyer: under NAR’s guidelines of May 2026, once an agent from another brokerage shows the home or brings an offer, the listing must go into the MLS within one business day.

A signed disclosure: ARMLS requires the seller to sign one before the listing starts, acknowledging the MLS benefits they’re waiving or delaying, “such as broad and immediate exposure of their listing.”

No advertising: any public marketing puts the home on the MLS within a business day (the rule is below). And under Zillow’s Listing Access Standards, a listing publicly marketed without being on the MLS within a business day isn’t shown on Zillow or Trulia for the life of its listing agreement.

If the price matters more to you than privacy, the full market is where the most buyers compete for a home.

A private period with an end date

A private sale doesn’t have to be open-ended. ARMLS sets no time limit on an Office Exclusive listing, so you can set an end date before it starts.

If the right offer comes by then, you sell privately. If it doesn’t, the home goes on the MLS on the date you set, where every agent and buyer can see it.

Coming Soon works the other way round. The home is in the MLS from the start but kept out of public view for up to 30 days, and it becomes Active on the 31st.

The rule that keeps it private: no public marketing

ARMLS’s Clear Cooperation rule (Rules § 8.0) says that within one business day of marketing a property to the public, the listing broker must submit it to the MLS. Public marketing includes window flyers, yard signs, public websites, brokerage websites (including IDX), email blasts, listing-sharing networks between brokerages and apps open to the public. The rule applies to office-exclusive listings.

So an off-market home is never on a sign, a website or social media while it stays off-market, this site included. That’s why this page describes the service and shows no off-market homes, and why the site keeps no list of buyers for them.

Arizona’s advertising rule adds its own condition: before a licensee puts up a sign or publishes online that a specific property is for sale, they need the owner’s written consent, and must take it down promptly when the owner asks (A.A.C. R4-28-502(I)).

How Aaron approaches it

Aaron starts by asking why you want a private sale, and then lays out what each option would give up, so the choice is yours and made in writing.

Fair housing law applies to every sale, private or not. Who hears about the home and who may make an offer can’t depend on race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status or national origin.

Your three options under ARMLS’s rules

Each one starts with a written listing agreement. They differ in who can see the home and when.

Listing on the MLS, Coming Soon and Office Exclusive compared (ARMLS Rules & Regulations, May 28, 2026)
OptionListed on the MLSComing SoonOffice Exclusive
In the MLSYes, within two days of the seller signingYes, with the Coming Soon statusNo
Public websites and portalsYes, through IDX and syndicationNo IDX display or portal syndication while Coming SoonNone: public marketing puts it on the MLS within one business day
How longThe listing agreement’s termUp to 30 days, then Active on the 31st. It can’t go back to Coming Soon, and a home can be Coming Soon only 30 of every 45 daysARMLS sets no limit while it isn’t publicly marketed, so you can set your own end date
What the seller signsThe listing agreementThe listing agreement and ARMLS’s exempt-listing disclosureThe listing agreement and ARMLS’s exempt-listing disclosure

How a private sale works

  1. Talk it through

    Why you want privacy, your timing, and what you’d need from a sale to say yes.

  2. Choose the option and the end date

    Listed, Coming Soon or Office Exclusive, with what each gives up and, for a private sale, the date the private period ends. You settle all of it before you sign anything.

  3. Sign the paperwork

    A written listing agreement and, for a private option, the exempt-listing disclosure ARMLS requires.

  4. Reach buyers privately

    One conversation at a time. There’s no sign, no listing online and no email blast, and you decide what’s shared.

  5. An offer, or the full market

    Aaron reviews each offer with you and handles the contract, inspections, appraisal and title through closing. If the right offer hasn’t come by the end date, the home goes on the MLS.

Questions about selling off-market

What is an off-market sale?

An off-market sale is a home sold without being advertised or entered in the MLS. In the Phoenix area that’s usually an ARMLS Office Exclusive listing: the seller directs the listing brokerage, in writing, not to put the home in the MLS and not to market it publicly. The seller still has a listing agreement and an agent.Source: ARMLS Rules & Regulations, May 28, 2026, § 8.7

What’s the difference between Office Exclusive and Coming Soon?

An Office Exclusive listing stays out of the MLS and isn’t publicly marketed at all; a Coming Soon listing is in the MLS but delays public marketing. Under ARMLS’s rules a Coming Soon listing isn’t shown through IDX or the portals, lasts at most 30 days and becomes Active on the 31st. Both need the seller’s signed exempt-listing disclosure.Source: ARMLS Rules & Regulations, May 28, 2026, §§ 8.7, 8.25 and 23.3.5

Can an off-market home be advertised at all?

No, not to the public. ARMLS’s Clear Cooperation rule says that within one business day of marketing a property to the public, the listing broker must submit it to the MLS, and that covers signs, window flyers, public and brokerage websites, email blasts and apps open to the public. NAR’s guidance allows sharing within the listing brokerage and one-to-one with clients.Source: ARMLS Rules & Regulations, May 28, 2026, § 8.0; NAR, MLS Clear Cooperation Policy and its FAQ

Will I get less for my home if I sell it off-market?

Nobody can say in advance; what’s certain is that fewer buyers will see it. The MLS puts a home in front of every agent and buyer at once, and that competition is what an off-market sale gives up. ARMLS requires the seller to sign a disclosure acknowledging the benefits they’re waiving, such as broad and immediate exposure.Source: ARMLS Rules & Regulations, May 28, 2026, § 8.7

Can I see off-market homes on this site?

No. Posting an off-market home on a website is public marketing, which would put it on the MLS within one business day under ARMLS’s rules, so this site never shows one and keeps no list of buyers for them.Source: ARMLS Rules & Regulations, May 28, 2026, § 8.0

Can an agent from another brokerage show my home while it’s private?

Not without it going into the MLS. NAR’s guidelines of May 2026 say that once an agent outside the listing brokerage shows an office-exclusive home, or negotiates an offer on it, the listing must be filed in the MLS within one business day.Source: NAR, Guidelines for 1-to-1 Broker Communication (May 21, 2026); ARMLS Rules & Regulations, May 28, 2026, §§ 8.0 and 8.7

How long can my home stay off-market?

ARMLS sets no time limit on an Office Exclusive listing while it isn’t publicly marketed, so it can stay private for the term of your listing agreement. You can also set an earlier end date for the private period, after which the home goes on the MLS. A Coming Soon listing is different: 30 days at most, then Active on the 31st.Source: ARMLS Rules & Regulations, May 28, 2026, §§ 8.7 and 8.25

The rules this page relies on

Checked November 18, 2026. Rules change; check the current versions.

Selling with Aaron

Fair housing

Talk to Aaron about a private sale

No obligation and no mailing list. Aaron replies personally. Text him and he answers most texts within 15 minutes, unless he’s with a client or it’s evening.

Still deciding whether to move? That’s a good time to talk.

602-785-5095

Office: 7975 N Hayden Rd, Suite A101, Scottsdale, AZ 85258

Aaron Benson standing at a marble kitchen island

Aaron Benson, REALTOR®Realty ONE Group

Your request wasn’t sent yet

Check your name and your phone number or email, then send it again.

    I’m thinking about
    About your search

    Optional. It helps Aaron prepare for your first conversation; every request gets the same reply.

    About the home (optional)

    An area like “Paradise Valley” is fine. You don’t need to give the address.

    Tell Aaron more (optional)
    What matters to you in a home?

    In your own words, up to 500 characters.

    Spam check by Cloudflare Turnstile